Anthropic trained Claude on illegally obtained Stanford professors' books(stanforddaily.com)
535 points by car 21 hours ago | 277 comments
tl;dr: A federal judge ruled in Bartz v. Anthropic that Anthropic illegally pirated books from shadow libraries like LibGen to train Claude, resulting in a $1.5 billion settlement covering ~500,000 works, though the judge found training on legally acquired books to be fair use. Stanford professors Tobias Wolff and Chang-rae Lee opted out and filed a separate suit, Cruz v. Anthropic, seeking up to $150,000 per infringed work versus the ~$3,000 per work in the class settlement. The Authors Guild is also lobbying Congress for legislation mandating AI training licenses.
HN Discussion:
  • ↑Double standard: Anthropic faces civil penalties while Aaron Swartz was criminally prosecuted for similar acts
  • ~The 'slave labor' framing by the professor is hyperbolic and poorly chosen
  • ↓The article's title is misleading since training itself was ruled fair use, only the piracy was illegal
  • ↑Fair use ruling for AI training is fundamentally wrong since models reproduce and monetize the ideas
  • ↑Anthropic needs existential-level penalties and strict auditing to deter this behavior industry-wide