Quad9 to exit France(quad9.net)
1342 points by farrokhi 3 days ago | 469 comments
tl;dr: Quad9, the Swiss nonprofit DNS resolver, will withdraw service from France on November 24 after a court ruled it must block domains accused of copyright infringement by beIN. The organization argues DNS-level blocking is technically unworkable (geoIP can be bypassed by VPNs, as proven in a prior Sony case in Germany) and that global blocking would improperly extend French law worldwide. With ~20 similar lawsuits pending, Quad9 says ongoing compliance risks are existential, and exiting France is the only way to preserve its mission of neutral, privacy-respecting DNS resolution.
HN Discussion:
  • ↑CTO clarifies the technical conflict between geoIP blocking and selective domain filtering challenges
  • ↑Frustration that complying operators get punished when plaintiffs circumvent their own blocks via VPN
  • ↑Punishing DNS resolvers is misguided, like blaming phone books for criminal listings
  • ↑Quad9 is targeted because it lacks financial resources, not due to legal merit
  • •Questions remain about the technical implementation of blocking given stated limitations