Anthropic's Scion is heavily inspired by Mononoke(sunshowers.io)
415 points by sunshowers 1 day ago | 155 comments
tl;dr: A former Meta engineer who helped build Mononoke, Facebook's open-source version control server, argues that Anthropic's newly announced Scion VCS heavily copies Mononoke's "derived data" design without crediting it—mentioning only Sapling for "hard-won lessons." The author doesn't object to the design being reused (that's the point of open source) but calls out Anthropic for implying Claude originated the ideas. He warns that as LLMs increasingly draw on existing open-source designs, properly crediting prior art becomes both easier and more essential.
HN Discussion:
  • ↓Anthropic cited Sapling which includes Mononoke, so the attribution complaint seems unfounded
  • ↑LLMs enable IP laundering by copying ideas without attribution, discouraging open sharing
  • ↑Anthropic essentially cloned existing work rather than contributing back, motivated by IPO valuation
  • ↑Confirms suspicion that Scion sounds strikingly similar to Sapling/Mononoke
  • ~Questions whether this level of citation is actually standard practice for software projects