How to Write with an LLM(sockpuppet.org)
743 points by joeriddles 26 days ago | 410 comments
tl;dr: Use LLMs as copyeditors, not ghostwriters, following two rules: never use an LLM's suggested wording (readers detect it instantly), and disable its default encouragement (which tricks you into keeping bad first-draft choices). Instead, have models flag mechanical problems—passive voice, filler words, structural issues—then rewrite yourself, and have a context-free model judge between versions to avoid sycophancy bias. The author also recommends the book "Style: Lessons in Clarity and Grace" for systematic prose editing.
HN Discussion:
  • ↑Writing your own text deepens understanding and prevents cognitive skimming
  • ~AI-generated writing degrades reading experience and shouldn't be used for human audiences at all
  • ↑LLMs are valuable specifically for fact-checking rather than style suggestions
  • ↓The advice is circular because judging LLM suggestions requires already having good taste
  • ↓LLMs have terrible taste and can't reliably judge which writing is better