Alternatives to MinIO for single-node local S3(rmoff.net)
257 points by rmoff 1 day ago | 101 comments
tl;dr: The author tests six drop-in replacements for MinIO as a single-node local S3 server: S3Proxy and RustFS are the easiest to swap in (though RustFS is alpha and had a recent security vuln), while SeaweedFS and Zenko CloudServer require minor tweaks. Garage and Apache Ozone technically work but are too heavyweight or complex for local demo use, requiring extra init steps or multi-node deployments. Ceph Object Gateway was dismissed for similar reasons.
HN Discussion:
  • Prefers the maintained MinIO fork (pgsty/minio) for simple local S3 simulation use cases
  • ~Endorses Garage as a solid choice, noting recent single-node setup improvements
  • Suggests additional alternatives the author didn't cover (Versity GW, hs5, Filestash)
  • Criticizes the article's framing as being about MinIO-compatibility rather than true single-node local S3
  • Shares production experience with RustFS/SeaweedFS confirming author's assessments about tradeoffs