Fable 5.1 Solves the Cyphral Distich, a 370-year-old cipher(vals.ai)
1208 points by u1hcw9nx 45 days ago | 566 comments
tl;dr: Claude Fable 5.1 solved Sir Thomas Urquhart's 370-year-old Cyphral Distich cipher by realizing the key was the book itself: each of the 64 numbers indexes a word in one of Urquhart's 32 Proquiritations, with the first letter of that word yielding a royalist prayer for Charles II. The model then applied the same technique (using page numbers instead of paragraphs) to largely decipher Urquhart's longer Cyphral Octastich from The Jewel (1652). The author frames this as evidence that LLMs can crack historical puzzles bottlenecked mainly by sustained human attention rather than raw cryptanalytic skill.
HN Discussion:
  • ↓The article overstates novelty; the book cipher solution was already proposed years ago in blog comments
  • ↓The framing is misleading since the cipher wasn't well-studied and the LLM cherry-picked a solvable problem
  • ~Recent LLM 'discoveries' reflect low-hanging fruit from lack of prior attention rather than true capability
  • ↓The decoded message is underwhelming and trivial, diminishing the impressiveness of the result
  • ↑Personal anecdote supports that LLMs can genuinely crack overlooked ciphers