Silicon Valley misreads science fiction and undermines democracy(techcrunch.com)
292 points by evo_9 12 days ago | 265 comments
tl;dr: Historian Jill Lepore, in her upcoming book "The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State," argues that private tech companies—led by figures like Musk and Altman—are quietly usurping the functions of democratic governments, pushing a "rule by algorithms" that no one voted for. She contends Silicon Valley leaders misread sci-fi warnings (from E.M. Forster to Asimov) as blueprints rather than cautionary tales, and that the artificial state is ultimately doomed because it destroys the natural resources it depends on. Local backlash against data centers, she suggests, is an early sign of democratic pushback.
HN Discussion:
  • Tech billionaires prioritize elite interests over democracy simply because wealth removed them from normal concerns
  • Anti-government brainwashing led to privatization that handed unelected businessmen excessive power
  • The article's argument about sci-fi being misread is confused or a strawman with no real evidence
  • Tech leaders like Musk clearly misunderstand the sci-fi they claim to admire
  • ~Interesting interview but disagrees with core conclusions; technology, not politics, drives historical change