Xbox goes down. You can't play games you own on disc(birchtree.me)
672 points by surprisetalk 1 day ago | 706 comments
tl;dr: An extended Xbox outage that started Sunday evening prevented users from playing not just digital titles but disc-based games as well, since discs today merely grant a license and require installs, updates, and network authentication to function. The author argues this exposes how modern "physical" console media isn't truly ownership—unlike old cartridges that still work standalone—and cites it as a reason to prefer PC gaming, where preservation options are more robust.
HN Discussion:
  • PC gaming and DRM-free platforms like GOG offer better ownership and preservation than consoles
  • ~The real issue is licensing and DRM, not physical vs digital media format
  • True ownership rights (offline use, resale, inheritance) should apply regardless of format
  • Server shutdowns will turn today's physical discs into e-waste, threatening game preservation
  • Previous console generations solved these problems better with offline/LAN support