Note-Taking and Personal Knowledge Management(unattributed.cc)
207 points by surprisetalk 5 days ago | 68 comments
tl;dr: A rebuttal to Brennan Kenneth Brown's critique of PKM tools like Obsidian, arguing that Brown mischaracterizes Obsidian's marketing, shifts his own thesis questions mid-article, and cites sources that don't actually support his claims. The author suggests Brown's rapid-writing workflow (750 words in 20 minutes with research filled in later) led to weak sourcing, and contends that tools like Obsidian shouldn't be judged by their loudest influencer-users but by whether they enable individuals to build systems that work for them.
HN Discussion:
  • Note-taking tools are just means to an end; judging them by outputs misses the point
  • Brown mischaracterized Obsidian and conflated it with specific PKM frameworks; personal incremental systems work best
  • ~Elaborate PKM systems often mask anxiety about learning rather than aid it
  • ~Traditional note-taking is less useful than learning by doing projects
  • Simpler tools (handwritten notebooks, Apple Notes) work better than dedicated PKM apps