'VPNs are lawful technical tools,' says EU Court in landmark copyright ruling(techradar.com)
589 points by healsdata 16 hours ago | 106 comments
tl;dr: The CJEU ruled that VPNs are "lawful technical tools" and that VPN providers aren't liable when users bypass geo-restrictions to access copyrighted content. The case involved a Belgian-hosted scholarly edition of Anne Frank's manuscripts that geo-blocked Dutch visitors (where the work is still under copyright until 2037); the court held that as long as publishers deploy "state-of-the-art" geo-blocking, they aren't liable for determined users circumventing it via VPN. The ruling shifts responsibility onto rightsholders and publishers rather than privacy tools or their users.
HN Discussion:
  • Clarifies the ruling is narrowly about copyright, not broader censorship/surveillance issues
  • Criticizes heirs/estates rather than original authors for aggressive copyright enforcement
  • VPNs are essential survival tools against surveillance pricing and IP-based discrimination
  • Ruling sets helpful precedent for VPNs against future attacks like age verification laws
  • ~Governments will simply target VPN providers directly or push users to private communities