What I learned selling 2,500 MIDI recorders: Hardware is not so hard(chipweinberger.com)
545 points by chipweinberger 1 day ago | 255 comments
tl;dr: After selling 2,500 units of Jamcorder (an automated MIDI piano recorder), the founder found hardware was far easier than expected—software (200K lines across firmware, app, and tooling) was by far the hardest part. He credits the smooth hardware experience to intentional simplicity: a single-PCB, single-screw design with 25 mostly off-the-shelf components, no USB-C, and no complex features. Key takeaways include keeping BOMs simple, aiming for 70%+ gross margins, partnering with Chinese suppliers via Alibaba, and holding QA and inventory in-house.
HN Discussion:
  • Hardware is hard for reasons beyond design: scale, user unpredictability, and edge cases
  • This product is at the simple end of hardware complexity, so the conclusion doesn't generalize
  • Regulations, certifications, and compliance are what actually make hardware hard
  • Satisfied customers praising the product and the founder's achievement
  • Curious questions about anti-counterfeit strategy and scaling thresholds not yet encountered