Kaiser nurses say AI, surveillance are making their jobs and patient care worse(localnewsmatters.org)
514 points by gnabgib 12 hours ago | 340 comments
tl;dr: Kaiser Permanente advice nurses say workplace surveillance and AI tools—including systems that grade their tone, empathy, and call length—are pressuring them to cut calls short (often under 15 minutes) at the expense of patient care, with some withholding compassion from suicidal or terminally ill patients to avoid poor performance scores. The California Nurses Association is heading into contract negotiations with AI as a central issue, while state lawmakers weigh several bills to regulate workplace AI, including protections for clinicians who override automated recommendations. Kaiser denies using average handle time to evaluate nurses.
HN Discussion:
  • Article conflates AI issues with call center metrics; actual AI tools help clinicians
  • Using machines to evaluate empathy or track workers is inherently wrong and harmful to care
  • Surveillance and bad metrics are an industry-wide problem degrading patient care
  • ~The article lacks concrete examples of AI harm; the real issue is cost-optimization
  • Study is motivated reasoning tied to union contract negotiations and misses real issues