First atmosphere found on Earth-like planet in habitable zone of distant star(bbc.com)
466 points by neversaydie 21 hours ago | 275 comments
tl;dr: Researchers have detected helium in the atmosphere of LHS 1140 b, a rocky exoplanet 48 light-years away orbiting in its red dwarf star's habitable zone—the first atmosphere confirmed on an Earth-like world in a Goldilocks zone. Helium alone can't support life, but other gases may exist lower in the atmosphere. The finding, published in Science, is a step toward answering whether Earth-like conditions exist elsewhere, though no biosignatures have been detected.
HN Discussion:
  • Skepticism that LHS 1140b is truly Earth-like, suggesting it may be a mini-Neptune being stripped by its star
  • Excitement about proximity and speculation on propulsion technology to send probes there
  • Focus should shift to the Fermi paradox and the narrow communication window problem
  • Skepticism that helium alone is meaningful, questioning the significance of the finding
  • ~Reminder that 'Earth-like in habitable zone' doesn't imply habitability, citing Venus as example