Should DayQuil Be Legal?(theargumentmag.com)
222 points by paulpauper 19 hours ago | 268 comments
tl;dr: Popular OTC cold medicines like DayQuil are largely combinations of one useful ingredient (acetaminophen) plus ineffective additives like dextromethorphan and phenylephrine—the latter the FDA has been trying to pull from shelves for years. Beyond the massive markups (up to 6,000%), these combo products drive dangerous unintentional acetaminophen overdoses, since patients stacking multiple cold meds often unknowingly quadruple their dose. The author argues the FDA should stop approving drugs based on weak efficacy evidence and separate acetaminophen from combo products entirely.
HN Discussion:
  • Acetaminophen overdose dangers are underappreciated and reinforce the article's warning
  • Article cherry-picks studies and misrepresents evidence about DXM's effectiveness
  • ~Real issue is restricted access to effective pseudoephedrine, forcing placebo alternatives
  • Misleading consumers should be illegal; accurate information is essential for markets
  • Consumers bear responsibility to research ingredients rather than blame OTC marketing