Why Switzerland has 25 gbit internet and America doesn't(stefan.schueller.net)
500 points by talonx 8 hours ago | 380 comments
tl;dr: Switzerland treats fiber as a natural monopoly, mandating point-to-point architecture with four dedicated fiber strands per home and open Layer 1 access, allowing multiple ISPs to compete over shared physical infrastructure — enforced by regulators who fined Swisscom 18M francs in 2024 for trying to switch to a shared P2MP model. In contrast, the US allows territorial monopolies with shared connections and no meaningful competition, while Germany wastes resources on redundant parallel builds ("overbuild"). The lesson: infrastructure should be built once as a neutral asset, with competition happening at the service layer.
HN Discussion:
  • Article is clickbait ignoring geographic scale and coverage nuances of the US
  • US ISPs provide humiliatingly poor service, reinforcing need for better infrastructure model
  • Multi-gigabit speeds are unnecessary in practice; 1Gbit is more than enough
  • Public investment and infrastructure regulation succeed elsewhere (Italy, Australia's failed NBN)
  • Raw speed numbers matter less than peering quality and real-world performance