Android Developer Verification: Threat masquerading as protection(f-droid.org)
1643 points by drewfax 1 day ago | 710 comments
tl;dr: F-Droid frames Google's mandatory Android Developer Verification (ADV) — rolling out September 30 in Brazil, Indonesia, Singapore, and Thailand — as a trojan-like system service that will block installation of apps from developers not centrally registered with Google. They argue the program does little to actually prevent malware distribution, forces developers to hand over ID and agree to vague terms where "malware" is undefined (and could be weaponized against ad-blockers or other disfavored software), and threatens F-Droid's open-source distribution model despite widespread opposition from EFF, FSF, ACLU, and over 70 organizations.
HN Discussion:
  • Users should switch to Linux-based mobile OSes to escape Google's control
  • F-Droid's tone is childish and undermines their credibility with mainstream audiences
  • Users have the right to install whatever they want on devices they own
  • Google itself is the real trojan/malware through pervasive data harvesting
  • Mandatory signing/verification threatens freedom, democracy, and tinkerer/developer autonomy