L'Affaire Siloxane(mceglowski.substack.com)
289 points by idlewords 2 days ago | 54 comments
tl;dr: Siloxanes—inert silicone compounds found in deodorants, lotions, and wipes—evaporate from astronauts on the ISS, get hydrolyzed by space radiation into dimethylsilanediol (DMSD), and contaminate the recycled water supply, fouling filters, heat exchangers, and the Sabatier reactor. NASA spent years identifying the culprit (even destroying gas chromatographs whose siloxane tubing kept contaminating samples) and has only partially mitigated it via hybrid HEPA/charcoal air filters, which caused a mold outbreak. The saga illustrates how mundane "unknown unknowns" and unsimulatable closed-loop interactions make life support engineering brutally hard—and pose serious risks for future Mars missions.
HN Discussion:
  • Industry professionals confirm siloxanes are pervasive contamination problems in their own work
  • Analogous cautionary tales (Ritonavir, Fogbank, Shuttle tiles) reinforce the unknown-unknowns thesis
  • Hope hard sci-fi will better depict these mundane life-support failure modes
  • Skepticism that NASA couldn't have eliminated siloxanes from shipped supplies
  • Modern detection sensitivity outpaces our ability to exclude contaminants, complicating measurements